Contact Claims

Toll Free: 800-382-8837 | Local: 765-457-9161 | Fax: 765-868-3310

Claims Team

Toll Free: 800-382-8837

Local: 765-457-9161

Fax: 765-868-3310

Peggy Hemming

Claims Leader

[email protected]

765-252-3034

Mary Kelter

Sr. Claims Representative

[email protected]

765-252-3032

Danella Ray

Sr. Claims Representative

[email protected]

765-252-3030

Andrea Grubb

Sr. Claims Representative

[email protected]

765-252-3017

Tricia Roark

Sr. Claims Representative

[email protected]

765-252-3009

Denis Boland

Sr. Claims Representative/ Subrogation Adjuster

[email protected]

765-252-3033

Shelli Bagley

Claims Representative II (Med Only)

[email protected]

765-252-3040

Aaron Copeland

Claims Representative II (Med Only)

[email protected]

317-969-8682

Gayle Trevithick

Claim System Liaison

[email protected]

765-252-3029

Chasidi Johnston

Claim System Liaison

[email protected]

765-252-3037

Tammy Smith

Claims Systems Liaison

[email protected]

765-252-3016